KKTV Online Poll
At what point will you stop filling up your gas tank?

$3.75
$4.00
$4.15
Never, I have places to be.


The Debate Over Ethanol As Alternative Fuel Save Email Print
Posted: 10:00 PM May 5, 2008
Last Updated: 1:40 PM May 6, 2008
Reporter: Mindy Stone
Email Address: MStone@kktv11news.com
6 comments Poll


A | A | A

It can save you money and help save the planet. That's what many drivers believe about ethanol fuel. But some say it's a scam.

 
Do you believe corn-based ethanol, also known as E-85, is the best alternative fuel?
Yes, it is the best alternative fuel.
Yes, I believe it is for now but we need to continue research into other options.
No, I think corn-based ethanol is a waste.
 

"This idea that we can replace foreign oil with ethanol is madness," said Author Robert Bryce.

What? We've been told for years, it's the best way to fuel the future. With gas prices on the rise and no relief in sight. A growing number of drivers are opting for flex fuel cars.

Around the world, fuels are being made with everything from grass, to sugar even vegetable oil.

Here in the U.S., it's corn based ethanol that's driving the change.

Drivers are saving a few dollars at the pump and reducing their cars' emissions.

"I think its a step in the right direction."

E-85 is 15 percent gasoline and 85 percent ethanol which can be made from corn and other crops. You can grow it and they're already doing it at farms in Southern Colorado.

Ethanol plants are popping up across the state too.

"I'd like to see it be the thing of the future,' said Robert Mauro, Co-Owner of Mauro Farms in Pueblo, 'I'd like them to build one here."

But there is a cost to ethanol. Right now, some people's grocery bills are higher because of it.

"If you look at labels on food products so many of them contain corn derived product from corn. As the price of corn has gone up, the price of foods that are produced with some use of corn go up," said Harlan Ochs, Acorn Petroleum.

Maybe an okay price to pay if it's going to help the environment. But some say it's barely doing that.

"People who are looking at overall need for energy would say this isn't a good exchange for it," said Ochs.

Some even believe it takes more energy to make ethanol than ethanol creates. But according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture, for every 100 units of energy used to make ethanol, we gain 167 units.

Still not enough for some.

"If there is an energy gain from production of Ethanol, it is very slight," said Bryce.

Author Robert Bryce has written a book called, Gusher of Lies: The Dangerous Delusions of Energy Independence.

Fifty-four pages of the book are devoted to what he calls, the ethanol scam. He says there's no shortage of oil in the world, so why shouldn't the U.S. keep using it?

"We are not going to be energy independent. we should not attempt to be energy independent," said Bryce.

But some say it's not about energy dependence. It's about the environmental impact.

President Bush is mandating alternative fuel usage, like E-85 of 36 billion gallons a year by 2022. Here in Colorado, Governor Bill Ritter has set a goal to reduce our greenhouse gas emissions by 20 percent over the next 12 years. The Colorado Corn Association says E-85 is helping us get there. But in the meantime, some worry it's not worth the price we're paying.

"We need to end the ethanol madness. The ethanol madness is costing us in many ways, and the costs are only growing," said Bryce.

Related Information:
Click here to learn more about theColorado Corn Growers Association

Click here to learn more about the Robert Bryce, author of Gusher of Lies. The Dangerous Delusions of Energy Independence Click Here

Email  del.icio.us   Google   Yahoo  digg
More Stories
Senator Kennedy Rushed to Hospital

State Democratic Convention Continues

State Democratic Assembly; First Time In Springs

I-25 Crash Kills Woman, 2 Boys

Smoke Billows From Colorado Springs Business Fire

May Announces Candidacy For DA

Hands-On Training For Colorado Springs Firefighters

Colorado Jobless Rate Holds Steady At 4.4 Percent

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Bill Location: Colorado Springs on May 6, 2008 at 04:35 PM
I have one E-85 car and I plan to convert the others. The increase in food costs are balanced with the savings in fuel costs, so it's a wash to me. If we end up paying more for corn and corn based products, then so be it. It's about time we paid American farmers instead of oil sheiks!

Posted by: Me Location: here on May 6, 2008 at 12:54 PM
Now that we have bought into the "AMERICAN DREAM", which is living outside the "AMERICAN NIGHTMARE", the city, we are being sold a whole new helping of BS by the same people that sold us the first BS to begin with, who just happen to be the same people who are SELLING US and OUR COUNTRY. Don't think so? You need to WAKE UP!

Posted by: Martinez Location: Southside on May 6, 2008 at 09:38 AM
Why shouldn't we attempt to be independent? Is Mr. Bryce supporting the terrorists? I would rather support LOCAL farmers, not arrogant bloodthirsty psychos in some desert. And as for the cost, I did the math, Petroleum has gone up 280% in 5 years, corn has gone up 45%, so what if I'm paying another 50 cents for corn flakes? It beats $4 gas any day. Ane we are making America better, any way you look at it.

Posted by: Carrie Location: 80916 on May 6, 2008 at 09:06 AM
Hemp is the best alternative for fuel. It is cheaper to grow than corn, it won't effect food prices and it would stop the war for oil. Hemp can be made into methanol, paper, rope , clothing, and so much more. Save our Earth and grow hemp! Stop the madness and get smart. If everyone knew the real truth behind why we don't use hemp for all our resources, they would know why the government is loaded and us tax payers are poor. They say it would put the paper and gas companies out of business, but why not turn it around and start a hemp business and profit just as much and help keep our Earth from being sucked dry of oil, trees, and cotton. God put it here for a reason and we aren't using it to our advantage because some paper and oil companies are worried about losing money. If I had a farm, I would grow it in mass quanities and prove to everyone that HEMP is the answer!

Posted by: bill Location: illinois on May 6, 2008 at 04:47 AM
Do you want to keep letting the govenment make us buying from other contries or do you want to make the usa some money and stop letting them get us for every penny we have just to stock pile gas for a war no one wants

Posted by: Chuck Location: Danley on May 5, 2008 at 10:42 PM
maybe there a few more units of energy created than consumed to make ethanol, but it isn't as many created by making gasoline. ethanol also consumes more energy units to move it from production to consumption because it can't move through existing pipelines like gasoline or diesel. e85 has 30% less power than regular gasoline and doesn't cost 30% less. consumers aren't really saving at the pump based on that.

National News - CBSnews.com