Does It Really Do That? Mr. Clean's Magic Eraser
To reach a Call for Action volunteer for help with a consumer problem call 457-8211 on Mondays, Tuesdays, and Thursdays from 11 a.m. to 1 p.m.
Save Email Print
Updated: 12:23 PM Nov 17, 2009
Does It Really Do That? Mr. Clean's Magic Eraser
It looks like a piece of white foam, not a cleaning product that can remove tough stains. So we decided to put Mr. Clean's Magic Eraser to the test to see... does it really do that?
Posted: 10:00 PM Nov 16, 2009
Reporter: Betty Sexton
Email Address: bsexton@kktv.com
Font Size:

His smiling face has graced the bottles of cleaning products for Proctor & Gamble for 50-plus years. Now Mr. Clean is best known for a piece of melamine foam.

It's called Magic Eraser...a white, cleaning stick you moisten with water then use to wipe up stains.

Michelle Defaria says it's her number one cleaning tool. She demonstrates how quick and easy it is to remove a scuff from this vinyl floor in the kitchen then tackle a mark on a refrigerator door. Plus, you can completely eliminate an old stain in a utility room, leaving a drastic contrast on the floor.

It also erased a red mark which has been on the wall for years.
Michelle says, "Overall I think it's a great product. I don't like to use a lot of chemicals when I'm cleaning so I love it... that you can just use water."

The teachers at Primrose School in Colorado Springs also use Magic Eraser. Tina McKenzie showed us how easily it wipes out what colored markers leave behind as well as crayons.

Tina says, "We clean up markers, we clean up crayons. Kids love to color on the tables. We get that good and clean, paint... anything that the kids are playing with that we can't get off other ways, we use our magic erasers."

Proctor & Gamble says they've heard from thousands of satisfied customers who use the Mr. Clean product everyday in their kitchens. One drawback we noticed, it starts to crumble after several uses like a pencil eraser. P&G says that's just the way it works. An abrasive built into the eraser simply erodes over time.

I'm also told to be sure to go back and wipe whatever surface you've erased to get rid of crumbled chunks. That way they can't swallowed by a child or pet.

Some Internet sites claim the foam is dangerous because it's made with formaldehyde, but Proctor & Gamble tells me that's not true. Formaldehyde has never been an ingredient in the eraser.

The product also removes annoying scuffs on white leather shoes and kills the scum that builds up on glass shower doors. But this isn't a miracle eraser. Read the directions and note which surfaces not to try. In some cases, it'll actually remove the paint from your walls.


Latest Comments

Posted by: CHRIS Location: CSPRINGS on Nov 17, 2009 at 10:56 PM

THE MAGIC ERASER WORKS WONDERS!! I LOVE THIS THING!I SERIOUSLY COULD NOT STOP TALKING ABOUT IT TO FRIENDS. ITS WONDERFUL, AND FOR THOSE WHO DONT LIKE IT AND DONT THINK IT DOES WELL THEIR HOUSE IS PROBABLY NASTY AND BEYOND REPARIABLE OR SOMETHING. HAHAHA.
Posted by: Bob Location: COS on Nov 17, 2009 at 03:34 PM

I use Spongebob for most of my cleaning. Patrick works well in the corners and Krabs is good for scraping.
Posted by: Sandra Location: C/S on Nov 17, 2009 at 11:37 AM

I don't like the "magic eraser". It falls apart way to fast and is way to expensive to have to replace everytime I want to deep clean. I think that a sponge/scrubber works just as well and you can get a pack of 3 for $1 at the Dollar Tree :)